Skip to main content
0333 577 7736
Non-Fault Claims

When At Fault Insurer Delays Hold Up Your Claim

At fault insurer delays can leave you without transport or answers. Learn what causes them, what you can claim, and how expert support keeps you moving daily.

When At Fault Insurer Delays Hold Up Your Claim
AA

Auto Assist Scotland Ltd

Accident Management Specialists

Non-Fault ClaimsPublished 29 July 20267 min read

A non-fault accident is disruptive enough without at fault insurer delays leaving you chasing updates, paying for travel or wondering when your car will be repaired. You may have clear details for the other driver, photographs from the scene and a police reference, yet the claim can still appear to stand still. The key is knowing what the insurer is waiting for, what support you can arrange now and when to put an experienced claims team in control.

Why at fault insurer delays happen#

An insurer does not always delay a claim because it is refusing to pay. In many cases, it is still investigating liability. It may need to speak to its policyholder, review vehicle damage, check dash-cam footage or assess whether the policy was active on the date of the collision.

This can be frustrating, particularly where the other driver accepted responsibility at the roadside. A verbal admission helps, but an insurer will usually make its own decision after reviewing the available evidence. If its policyholder cannot be contacted, disputes the account of events or provides a different version of events, the process can take longer.

Delays can also arise where there is incomplete information. Registration details, witness contacts, accident location, photographs and a clear account of what happened all help move a claim forward. For taxi drivers and people who rely on their vehicle for work, delays can have an immediate effect on income as well as day-to-day travel.

Some cases are genuinely more complex. Multi-vehicle collisions, injuries, unclear road layouts and incidents involving uninsured drivers may need more detailed investigation. That does not mean you should be left without practical help while the paperwork continues.

What you can do while liability is being considered#

Your first priority is safety and mobility. Arrange recovery if the vehicle is unsafe to drive, keep the damaged vehicle secure and obtain an estimate or assessment for repairs. Do not continue driving a car with damage that could make it dangerous or worsen the loss.

Keep a simple record from the start. Save photographs, video footage, repair documents, recovery invoices, correspondence and receipts for reasonable accident-related expenses. If you need taxis, public transport or other temporary travel, retain proof of the cost and why it was necessary.

You should also notify your own insurer, even if you do not intend to make a claim through your policy. Most policies require notification of an incident. Notification is not the same as accepting fault, and it does not automatically mean you must lose your no-claims discount. Ask your insurer to explain how it will record the incident and whether it will pursue recovery.

Avoid agreeing to a cash settlement or authorising repairs based solely on a brief phone call from the other insurer. Once you settle, it may be harder to recover additional reasonable losses that become clear later, such as storage, recovery, replacement transport or loss of earnings. Ask for any offer in writing and make sure you understand exactly what it covers.

Do not let a delayed decision leave you stranded#

If you were not at fault, you may be entitled to recover reasonable losses from the responsible party’s insurer. Depending on the circumstances, this can include vehicle recovery, storage, repairs, replacement transport, taxi costs, injury-related losses and, for eligible working drivers, some loss of use or earnings.

What is reasonable depends on the facts. A replacement vehicle should meet your genuine needs, but it should not be unnecessarily expensive or used for longer than required. A prestige vehicle owner, for example, may have a legitimate need for a comparable vehicle. A taxi driver may need a suitable licensed replacement to continue working. Evidence of that need matters.

This is where independent accident management can make a real difference. Rather than waiting for the at-fault insurer to appoint its own repairer, offer a courtesy car or dictate the pace of the claim, a specialist can arrange recovery, secure storage, repairs and an appropriate replacement vehicle while pursuing the recoverable costs.

That approach is not suitable for every case. If liability is strongly disputed, if there are concerns about the circumstances of the accident or if you may share responsibility, the options and funding arrangements need careful consideration. A good provider will explain the position clearly rather than promising an outcome before the evidence is reviewed.

How to strengthen a non-fault claim#

The strongest claims are clear, well documented and proportionate. Write down your account while the incident is fresh: the time, road, weather, direction of travel, traffic conditions and what each vehicle did. Note any witnesses and ask whether they are willing to provide contact details.

Photographs can be particularly useful. Capture the position of the vehicles where safe to do so, road markings, signs, damage, debris and wider views of the scene. Dash-cam footage should be downloaded and preserved promptly, as some devices overwrite recordings after a short period.

Be accurate in every conversation. It can be tempting to fill gaps when you are upset or under pressure, but speculation creates room for confusion later. If you are unsure of a detail, say so. Provide what you know and let the evidence support the claim.

You should also respond promptly to reasonable requests for information. An insurer may ask for proof of ownership, a driving licence, repair authority or confirmation of your vehicle’s pre-accident condition. Delays at this stage are often avoidable, and a claims handler can help make sure the response is complete.

When should you escalate the issue?#

A short period of investigation is not unusual. The concern is when there are repeated promises of an update with no meaningful progress, no explanation of what is outstanding, or no practical provision for your mobility. Ask the insurer or your representative specific questions: has liability been accepted, what evidence is still required and when will the next decision be made?

If you are dealing with the other insurer directly, keep communication in writing where possible. A clear email trail makes it easier to show what was provided and when. If you speak by phone, record the date, the name of the person you spoke to and the substance of the conversation.

Where the other insurer has accepted liability but repairs or payment are still being held up, ask for the reason in writing. It could be awaiting an engineer’s report, parts availability, policy checks or a disagreement over costs. Each issue needs a different response. A parts delay at a repair centre is not the same as an insurer failing to assess a claim.

For an unresolved complaint about an insurer’s service, follow its formal complaints process. If you remain dissatisfied after its final response, or after the relevant time limit has passed, you may be able to take the matter to the Financial Ombudsman Service. This route concerns service and complaint handling; it does not replace the need to establish who was legally responsible for the accident.

Get practical support before the pressure builds#

A delayed insurer decision should not force you to manage recovery, storage, repairs and transport alone. Auto Assist Scotland can coordinate the immediate response to a non-fault accident, including 24/7 recovery, secure vehicle storage, approved repairs and suitable replacement transport, while managing the claim process with the aim of recovering costs from the at-fault insurer.

The benefit is not simply convenience. It is having one team gather the right information, keep the claim moving and explain your options in plain English. That can be especially valuable when you need a vehicle for work, have been injured, or are facing a dispute over liability.

After an accident, act early, keep the evidence safe and ask for clear answers. The sooner the right support is in place, the less chance an insurer delay has to disrupt your life.

Share this article

Involved in a non-fault accident?

Speak to Auto Assist Scotland — recovery, repair, replacement vehicle and injury claims handled for you.